Walden goes looking for Mrs. Right while Alan has an opportunity to reconcile with Lyndsey.

After Heather drops a bombshell, a visit from Abby’s parents is the last thing Colt needs — and they all end up at church together on Christmas Eve.

Colt smooths things over with Abby. When Maggie drags Beau to the Marriott for a romantic evening, the guys have some fun back at the house.

When his inflated ego lands him in hot water, Colt realizes he’s not the big man on campus anymore. Beau’s doctor makes him trade in steak for salad.

Colt runs into an ex at Maggie’s bar and reminisces with Rooster over a bottle of whiskey. Getting back in Beau’s good graces is a losing battle.

When Colt Bennett returns home from Canada to try out for a semipro Denver team, he learns that his family’s ranch has fallen on hard times.